So it seems that after four years of 9x5 use, my bulletproof Logitech M570 Wireless Trackball has developed an issue. My left mouse button, or rather the micro switch inside, has malfunctioned. The end result being erratic double-clicks happening even when only a single button press is made. Why is this a potentially serious problem and how can you remedy it? Read on for the full story.
BACKGROUND:
My previous pointing device of six years had been a similar trackball - a wired Logitech Trackman Wheel USB version. This had stood up well to the punishing use it was put under. The switches in that trackball were solid, and had never shown signs of fatigue even after what I'm guessing was close to 6 million clicks over the course of all those years.
The newer M570 went under more than a cosmetic redesign. It's apparent immediately that only the left/right buttons use micro switches, the scroll wheel and back/forward buttons use the lesser quality rubber dome assemblies. This was disappointing for me to some point, because I am aware of just how good a durable micro switch is under years of heavy use.
And yet while I haven't seen issues with either the scroll wheel or the back/forward buttons, it's ironically the micro switch in my M570 that has been acting up. More specifically, the heavily-used left mouse button has been making erratic double-clicks, even with just a single button press. That can make using your system not only difficult, but introduce some serious problems as well.
DETAILS:
Double-clicks are great for when you want to quickly open a directory/file, minimize a window, highlight a word or start a program. The idea is that you just press a button once for it to happen instead of clicking twice with the left button on your trackball/mouse. Sounds great and works great in practice, but it can be more than a headache when it doesn't work properly.
In my case, I actually prefer a double-click pressing the left button twice, just out of old-school habit when I began working with computers, and mice from back in the day didn't have the feature. I tried using the middle button as a double-click, but it didn't feel right for me, so I've left the scroll wheel button on my M570 at it's default rapid scroll setting, handy for flying up/down a long web page.
Now you can imagine the difficulty of having that left mouse button working the opposite, doing double-clicks when only a single click is what I wanted. Trying to move windows became maddening as they would go full-screen as soon as I tried to drag them. Clicking on links would take me places that I didn't want to go, or open two browser tabs. Editing text became difficult, as instead of placing the cursor I would highlight an entire word/paragraph.
Even worse was the possibility of doing some real damage when clicking the send button on emails - I would get duplicate entries showing in my sent box, and my recipient would get sent the same email twice. That's not the way you want to look good communicating with important clients.
But the most dangerous result of all can be when doing financial activities online. Double-clicking on a submit payment button can do more than just ruin your day. It's bad enough being double-charged and then correcting the error after the fact. Such mistakes can affect a line of credit, and if it's items being shipped to you, getting them returned to the merchant. Transferring funds from one account to another? You definitely don't want to jerk around with your bank and appear to not have sufficient funds in the account.
THE FIX:
It's unfortunate that problems like these only raise their head after extended use. By then any warranty on your device is long expired. But before you run out and buy a brand-new replacement, or smash your M570 against the floor in a fit of rage after seeing your finances wiped out, there's a relatively easy fix that you can do thanks to Windows.
Tame those erratic double-clicks |
This method has taken care of my M570 for the time being, and I'm hoping it will work well enough to let me keep using the trackball without having to buy a replacement.
In reality, though, I think Logitech needs to take a serious look at the quality of the parts they are using and the reliability of their products. It's one thing for advancements in technology to make their way into newer devices. But that shouldn't come at the cost of making what once was an extremely solid and reliable product into something that looks prettier, yet fails prematurely. My wired USB Trackball was still working fine after six years of use, this model is already having issues after just four.
A company that compromises on quality is a company that will fail. And that's even without the damage done by bad press.
MAINTAINING YOUR TRACKBALL'S PERFORMANCE:
It's important to take care of your trackball as it will not only maintain it's performance, but keep it working in top condition.
Many users new to trackballs complain of stiff friction on their ball. Every new trackball will need a few weeks use to "break in". If that ball is feeling a little stiff out-of-the-box, it's only because it hasn't been fingered an awful lot. Give it a few weeks and that coarse feel will eventually become smooth.
The same is also true for the scroll wheel. If the friction is a little tight or the detents too hard it's again only because it is new and hasn't been used. I noticed after a few weeks that the wheel would roll much easier than when new, and the detents would soften out.
Being that we are talking about trackballs, it's very important as well to regularly remove that ball and clean the three tiny bearings that allow the ball to spin freely. Residue from skin will over time accumulate around these spots, and left there, will impede the bearings and make the ball harder to move, or jam it up entirely.
It's a relatively simple affair to pop that blue ball out by sticking your pinkie in the hole provided underneath, or if you have sausage fingers, the end of a pencil. Once removed, you will see where the gunk is, and again using a finger nail, easily pry away the offending material. Hey, it's from your own skin, so don't be repulsed by it. This would be a good time too to check the area where the sensor is and make sure that is free of any obstructions as well. Once done, pop the ball back in and regain your smooth trackball.
I recommend using the power button to preserve your trackball's battery, especially if you carry it often and have it stashed in a bag. But if turning it on doesn't get your trackball working, it may just be a sign of a bad contact. You can pop the bottom cover off and just rotate the battery a little or take it out and re-seat it. You'll know you're good when the light comes on. If you have a blinking light, though, it's time to replace the battery with a fresh one.
CONCLUSION:
As big a fan I am of the Logitech M570 Wireless Trackball, any reliability issues will quickly turn that opinion around. I was impressed with the six years of performance of the wired USB model, so that experience should also be expected of the newer version.
Keep in mind as well that out of the five M570 trackballs I have scattered around me and in use, TWO of them have problematic micro switches, one of which is maybe only 2-3 years old. True, I put heavy use on my trackballs, more than the average consumer. But a 40% component failure rate is very high and would concern me as a manufacturer.
It's important to give a manufacturer the opportunity to address any concerns and correct products that don't perform as intended. I'm hoping that the folks at Logitech read this, and their product engineers make the necessary tweaks to their button and micro switch assembly. I would hate to have the M570 end up being the topic of discussion again... in my Shame File.
UPDATE!!!
First of all, a big thank you to everyone who has read and/or commented here. It's great to be able to get into a real discussion and even more useful when I see the very good input being provided. As for the M570 itself, I can confirm that Logitech has replaced and is now using a different micro switch. I purchased a trio in late 2016 - taking the unit apart you can see the newer (black) switches being used as opposed to the original cyan-colored inferior ones. This should now eliminate for good the problem cited in the article above.
Thank you also to Logitech for listening to user feedback and fixing a serious product flaw. Ironically enough, they've been building these devices for well over a decade and simply should not have gone with such a sub-par component choice. It's really unfortunate that many many users (myself included) ended up with bad trackballs. No reputable company should EVER treat it's paying customers as quality control testers, and in that regard, I genuinely hope that this was a good lesson learned for Logitech when it comes to using inferior components versus quality parts.
RELATED CONTENT:
Thank you!
ReplyDeleteNice! I was having trouble with mine not registering clicks near the bottom of the screen. Never even thought it could be gunk build-up related but after reading this I figured it couldn't hurt. It is working better. The only remaining issue is when it gets REALLY sluggish. It seems turning it on and off a couple of times often helps.
ReplyDeleteSluggishness could be due to a problem USB port too. I noticed some intermittent behavior with mine recently with the summer temps, but it was because my notebooks USB port sits shotgun to the CPU heatsink's metal which was pulling 85C. Evidently the little dongle doesn't like high temperatures, and may fail over a sustained time at those temps.
DeleteI have several of these. I find the best way to get the ball moving smoothly from the beginning is to pop it out from the start and just roll it around in your hands for a couple minutes. The oil from your skin is sufficient lube with out making it feel greasy.
DeleteLong time trackman user.
ReplyDeleteHere's a tip. To make the ball roll smoothly right out of the box, place a very light 'dab' of plumbers grease OR petroleum jelly on the three 'dots' the ball rolls over.
The problem with lubrication is the oil then gets on the ball, and then ends up on your thumb. That's like eating greasy food and then touching your mouse. Your hands should always be clean and the ball kept dry.
DeleteBangem is close but overkill. The natural oils in your skin is sufficient without making it greasy. Just pop the ball out and roll it around in your hands for a couple minutes and it does the trick. I have several of these trackballs at work and home and have done this with everyone after the first.
DeleteThank you for the info on the double-clicking! This has just start cropping up on my M570 the last couple of months, so I will try to follow your recommendation on slowing up the double-click speed. I love the M570 as I use it a crucial piece of equipment which makes my Chartplotter Programs for my boat very user friendly as well as in regular day to day usage. Thx again!
ReplyDeleteWhy does this buildup have to be constantly cleaned every couple of hours?
ReplyDeleteNot every couple of hours, but checking it every two weeks or once a month is good.
DeleteLeslie's estimate is more like it. Even using my M570 for 8+ hours a day, cleaning it every one or two weeks works fine.
DeleteBut to answer your question, the reason why it has to be cleaned regularly is because, unlike a regular mouse, you're actually touching the ball that the laser is tracking. Your sweat greases up the ball, muck starts sticking to it, and that starts clogging up the little rollers for the movement, and can interfere with the laser, too. But that's exactly why the trackball is designed to make removing and cleaning the ball very easy.
Thanks for the tips. I have been having the same unintended double-clicking issue for a while. Only today I concluded I was due for a new one. Crowing the web for best deals led me to your article. Very timely!
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing this tip regarding the erratic double-clicking of the left mouse button. I agree with you; this issue never came up with the (needlessly discontinued) wired version of the trackball mouse.
ReplyDeleteMy track wheel was going crazy. I took apart the mouse by removing the 5 screws. One is under the battery sticker. I cleaned the optics for the wheel and wheel itself. Still had the issue. Even with the wheel off, it was going crazy. I took a Q-tip and some electronics cleaner and cleaned the circuit board, making sure to get between the legs of each component. This last step fixed it. There must have been a build up over time on the surface of the board causing intermittent communication between some of the components. It runs like new now!
ReplyDeleteThe inadvertend double-click has been an M570 problem for years, I wonder why Logitech hasn't replaced the guilty switches yet. It never happened to me with older models, and I don't hear about this with other Logitech mice, but I'm on my third M570 now that starts exhibiting the problem after approximately the same time, 6 months of heavy daily use. It does fix itself again after a few weeks though, no change required, and my M570s tend to have a lifespan of more than two years, the double-click problem never returns.
ReplyDeleteIt's a phase weirdly lodged between the breaking-in and wearing-out of the switch, and it seems so random that it's impressive how consistently it seems to happen to everyone.
What I found is that pressing down on the button with heavy force for a bit will fix the problem temporarily, so the trackball can be used fine until the faulty double-click phase is over for good. Use force on your device on your own risk, I'm not responsible if you break it entirely, but this seems to have worked for me. I also sometimes remove some grime and muck from in between and under the buttons using a sheet of paper, which helps solve problems with clicking haptics, but maybe doesn't influence the switch problems.
That's an interesting trick putting force on it to solve the issue. I'm going to have to dig out my faulty M570 and give it a try.
Delete